Geographical Society of Ireland
  • Home
    • Membership >
      • Join or Renew
      • Rules of the society
    • About the GSI
    • Event Funding/Sponsorship
    • Society Awards Programme
    • GSI Postgraduate Network
    • Supporting Women in Geography
  • Annual Conference
  • Irish Geography
    • Geo News
  • Events
    • GeoWeek 2020
    • Previous GeoWeek Events
  • Geography in Ireland
    • Resources
    • IRLOGI
    • AGTI
    • Jobs in Geography
    • Careers in Geography
  • IGC2024
  • GSI News

The relevance of geography to cardiac care in the South-East

10/7/2019

0 Comments

 

​Darren O’Rourke
​(Doctoral student at the Department of Geography, Maynooth University)


People in Waterford and the South-East will be very familiar with the community demand for 24/7 cardiac care for the local population and with the popular campaign that has grown from this call. There have been public demonstrations, lobbying of local and national politicians, including Ministers, reports commissioned and reports contested. At the heart of this issue is the way we (spatially) organise our public health services.
 
My PhD research at the Department of Geography at Maynooth University is directly relevant to this. My area of research interest is the politics of major health service change and particularly the way the public are involved in change processes. My research recognises the current processes of change as deeply problematic and aims to find out if there is a better alternative.
 
In many respects, the challenge faced by the community in Waterford and the South-East is similar to the challenge faced by communities in Dundalk, Mallow, Ennis, Roscommon, Bantry, Monaghan and Loughlinstown, previously, when it was proposed to close their local emergency departments. The similarity in terms of the nature of the service (urgent and emergency) and the importance of geography and proximity is clear. The community in Portlaoise are currently engaged in a similar with respect to the Emergency Department at the Midlands Regional Hospital Portlaoise.  
 
The Case is Made
On the one hand, leading doctors, health service managers and Government politicians point to the necessity to centralise services. The case is made in the interest of safety (doctors need to see a certain volume of patients of a particular type to maintain their skills), in the interest of cost and efficiency, and/or in the interest of staffing (“we cannot recruit sufficient numbers of staff to regional centres”). Reference is made to “international best practice” and “centres of excellence” and evidence from home and abroad is presented to support the case.
 
On the other hand, communities, often supported by local clinicians and politicians (usually from Opposition parties) contest each of the arguments put forward by those who want change. Communities argue that patients will, in fact, be put at risk by being further away from essential services. They will argue that the local hospital services are not only essential in terms of providing timely access but that they have an intrinsic, economic and symbolic value to the region/local community.
 
In Ireland we have numerous cases of communities engaging in very high level debates regarding the provision of services. I immediately think of the case of Dr. Patrick McHugh in Roscommon Hospital who challenged the Minister for Health’s assertion that cardiac patients attending at Roscommon had mortality rates four times worse than those attending Galway University Hospital. I think too, of the case put forward on an RTÉ Primetime programme by Dr. Ray Griffin of Waterford Institute of Technology which directly challenged the HSEs assertion that cardiac patient transfers from University Hospital Waterford to Cork and Dublin hospitals could be achieved in less than 90 minutes.
 
What’s important, for my research, is the appreciation and recognition of the differences of perspective and opinion between those seeking change and those resisting change. My research aims to look at the process of health service change. As a geographer I am interested in the importance of “place” and “locality”. After reviewing the Irish and international literature, I believe it is important to look at health service change, not as a technical exercise of drawing lines on a map and saying “we’ll move this service here and that service there”. Instead I agree with a number of famous researchers who see health service change as an inherently political process (particularly if we understand politics in the broad sense as “the way we get on in the world”).
 
There has been considerable research conducted internationally, particularly in the NHS in Britain, but also in New Zealand, Australia and Canada, that show us that trends towards centralisation of hospital services are not unique to Ireland. Nor is community resistance. High profile examples of community resistance to proposed health service changes are documented in places as far apart and diverse as Kiddeminister and London in Britain and the rural Maori community of Hokianga on the north island of New Zealand.
 
My research will be conducted over 3 phases. Over the course of the 3 phases I will work not only with colleagues at Maynooth University and University Collage Cork, but with international colleagues at Oxford University and University College London in Britain and the University of Auckland in New Zealand. Researchers and policy-makers are very interested in these issues because they recognise deep (and costly!) difficulties with the current processes of major health service change and, like me, wonder if there is a better way forward.
Phase 1
In the Phase 1 of my research, I will compare historical policy documents from Ireland to examine how they approached the challenge of planning health services across the country. These documents include the:
  1. Hospital Commission First General Report (1933-34)
  2. Report of the Consultative Council on the General Hospital Services (1968)
  3. Report of the National Task Force on Medical Staffing (2003)
  4. Houses of the Oireachtas Committee on the Future of Healthcare Sláintecare Report (2017)
 
When reading the policies and the debates that followed them, I will be guided by a specific framework for policy analysis developed by Australian academic Carole Bacchi, and ask the following questions:
  1. How has the “problem” of planning our health services in a fair and equitable way been represented in these policies?
  2. What assumptions underlie this representation of the “problem”?
  3. How has this representation of the “problem” come about?
  4. What is left unproblematic in this problem representation? Where are the silences?
  5. What effects are produced by this representation of the “problem”?
  6. How and where has this representation of the “problem” been produced, disseminated, and defended? How has it been and/or can it be questioned, disrupted, and replaced?
 
This particular approach to analysing policy allows the researcher to examine and challenge the underlying assumptions of particular policy proposals. It also allows us to see if there are alternative policy options that have been ignored or dismissed and to consider why this might be the case.
 
Phase 2
It has been suggested that involving the public – not just health service managers and clinicians and politicians but ordinary members of local communities – in decisions about how health services are planned leads to better-informed decisions and better outcomes (for patients, the public, politicians, clinicians and health service managers alike).  This idea is not new and stems from the idea that we each have something useful “to bring to the table” when big decisions are being made. It is argued that involving the public can:
  1. give the public a better understanding of the challenges faced by health service managers and clinicians (to deliver safe and effective care within strict budgetary constraints for example)
  2. give health service managers and clinicians a better understanding of the priorities and preferences of service users and local communities
 
In Phase 2 of my research, I will conduct an extensive review of the international literature to examine:
  1. How patients and the public have been engaged in decisions about major health service change in the past (in Ireland and internationally)?
  2. How this patient and public involvement has affected decisions about major health service change?
  3. Which methods of patient and public involvement have had the greatest impact on decisions and which are likely to be sustainable/repeatable?
  4. How have differing opinions about major health service change between patients, the public, politicians, clinicians and health service managers been negotiated and resolved?
Similar to phase 1, the findings of phase 2 will be of immediate interest and relevance to people in Waterford and the South-East.
 
Phase 3
In the final phase of my research, Phase 3, I intend to bring together all of the knowledge and ideas generated in phases 1 and 2 to ask the full range of people interested in our health services how they believe the current process of major health service change could be improved.
 
I will speak to a wide range of people including: members of the public, members of hospital campaign groups (such as the Still Waiting Campaign in the South-East), hospital doctors and GPs, local politicians and national politicians, health service managers and health service workers.
 
In this phase of research, I will employ a particular approach which allows participants to look at different models of public involvement and select their own particular preferences. In this way we can begin to identify the principles and characteristics of “good involvement” in major health service change.
 
Concluding Comments
In addition to my position as a Doctoral Student at Maynooth University, I am also a local County Councillor for the Sinn Féin party in County Meath and a member of the Dublin North East Regional Health Forum. There is significant overlap in my political and research interests. Like all quality research though, mine must be conducted to the highest ethical standards as set down and overseen by the Maynooth University Ethics Committee. All of my research will be publicly available (interim results in 2019 and 2020, final results expected 2021).
 
It is hoped that this research project will contribute to a deeper understanding of the politics of major health service change and point towards a better (more inclusive?) way forward.
 
Such an outcome would be of interest and use to local communities, health service decision-makers and policy-makers of all political persuasions
0 Comments

Galway Geography Conferences - May 2019

13/5/2019

0 Comments

 
Picture

This year 
Geography at NUI Galway will be hosting the 7th EUGEO Congress in conjunction with the 51st Conference of Irish Geographers, in Galway City in the west of Ireland. The conference will take place over four days (May 15th – 18th 2019) and the theme for the 2019 conference is Re-Imagining Europe's Future Society and Landscapes. The theme focuses on the centrality of the concepts of society and landscape within the Discipline of Geography and the importance of the relationship that exists between the physical and cultural landscape.
​

There will be over 500 delegates attending the conference representing an astonishing 37 countries. This conference will offer participants the opportunity to reflect on and re-imagine futures within the geographical boundary of Europe. The overarching theme is reflected throughout the conference programme and themed fieldtrips (programme available here). The aim of this broad and inclusive theme was to attract a wide variety of geographers with a range of physical, social, cultural, political and environmental research interests. The conference promises to be a very enjoyable event in a vibrant city and includes an exciting programme of social events (available here).
0 Comments

Transition Galway - #yearofgeography

13/5/2019

0 Comments

 
Picture
By Mary Greene

Transition Galway is a community-based organisation focused on engaging the community around environmental change. It is a local-based initiative that forms part of a larger international network, The Transition Town Network. Founded in 2011 by a group of local residents, Transition Galway has been involved in a range of efforts to engage the community around issues of environment, risk, resilience and sustainability. These have included efforts around engaging a wider public through processes of ‘mainstreaming’ involving organising series of public talks, film nights, community gardening, radio series, fieldtrips, outdoor activities and social media activities to name a few.

The group is divided into a series of sub groups that work on various thematic dimensions of community engagement around issues of food, energy, education, outreach and psychological. Community visioning is another engagement tool that is central to the transition approach to community engagement. Transition Galway organised a series of public visioning engagement activities that involved creating a space for members of the local community to articulate their vision for a more sustainable and resilient Galway in 2030. The results of this process were published in a publicly accessible handbook ‘A vision for Galway 2030’ and accompanying short summary videos available online at galwaytransition.wordpress.com. Material and projects from this process was included in the successful Galway 2020 cultural capital bid application and Galway City Council Development Plan.

Since its inception, TG has worked to actively participate as a key player in the environmental governance landscape in Galway and Ireland more broadly. To this end, forging relations with a range of governance actors, including Galway City Council, Galway Chamber, the arts community, schools and other environmental and community development groups in Galway and beyond. Barriers to community engagement experienced by the group have included limited access to funding, maintaining ongoing momentum of voluntary people resources, group dynamics and accessing public space.


Website: https://transitiongalway.wordpress.com/
​

0 Comments

In Memory of Gordon Herries Davies (1932-2019)

13/3/2019

2 Comments

 
By Arnold Horner

Gordon Davies, otherwise Gordon Leslie Herries Davies (he favoured the latter form from the late 1970s), who died on 22 February 2019 was one of the most significant figures ‘doing Geography’ in Ireland during the second half of the last century. A graduate of the University of Manchester, Gordon became an assistant lecturer at Trinity College Dublin in  1954.
His association with the college as lecturer and later professor, extended over five decades. Gordon’s teaching remit initially centred on physical geography, particularly geomorphology, but his other offerings included courses on the history and philosophy of geography, and his research interests eventually combined and expanded on these areas.

Those who took his courses will remember him as a much-respected, distinctive and original teacher, who was accessible to, and respectful of, his students – a person who was on occasion truly inspirational. Gordon was the author of numerous articles, and several major books, among them The earth in decay (1969, a history of geomorphological studies), Sheets of many colours (1983, on Irish geological mapping), North from the Hook (1995, on the Geological Survey of Ireland), and Whatever is under the Earth (2007, on the Geological Society of London).

He also edited several major volumes, including a series of essays on Richard Griffith (1980) and the Golden Jubilee volume of Irish Geography (1984). From 1968 to 1978 he was editor of Irish Geography, and later he was an editor of the Annals of Science. Gordon initiated and was active in a wide range of intellectual projects in Ireland and abroad. His original opinions, his wide-ranging knowledge and his innate curiosity about the past and about studying the physical world helped make him a true scholar. At the same time, he cultivated a distinctive writing style that consciously sought to make his work accessible and readable, as well as rigorous, for the widest audience. As well as editing Irish Geography, Gordon served the Geographical Society of Ireland as president from 1962 to 1964. He was a committed and enthusiastic supporter of the Society and of Geography in general over a much longer period. He was also very much committed to Trinity College
Dublin and to such organisations as the Royal Irish Academy. In recent decades, he lived in Tipperary and on North Uist, Outer Hebrides, a place that he first visited in the 1950s.

Gordon will be remembered with respect and affection by those who had the good fortune to learn from, and interact with, him as a geographer.
2 Comments

Exploring Abandoned Cork

7/3/2019

0 Comments

 
Place-hacking, or urban exploration, is the exploration of buildings and structures, usually abandoned ruins or not normally seen places in the human-made environment. The cultural geographer, Dr Bradley Garrett (http://www.placehacking.co.uk/), highlighted the rich sub-culture of urban exploration and the insights it granted to parts of cities and buildings most people never experience. There is a small community of place-hackers in Cork, among them is the @abandoned_westcork Instagram account (https://www.instagram.com/abandoned_westcork/) that explores abandoned places across the county.
​
The photos are a fascinating, and sometimes upsetting, insight into the geographies and histories of Ireland. Images of the Allihies copper mines or a former tuberculosis sanatorium present ages gone by, with once incredibly important places fading away.  Family portraits, religious statues, and furniture slowly rotting are found in abandoned homes, each one telling a story of a family gone. While, other images show the waste of amazing buildings or potential housing lying idle and falling into disrepair. The account is a powerful and evocate examination of Cork and Irish society.

Explaining their desire to enter these parallel worlds, the explorer explained that “I think I started it to give myself a distraction while trying to come to terms with a personal trauma. I must admit on a different level, as a child I was always more interested in what was behind the barriers than following all the tourist around the marked out path, needless to say I got in trouble on numerous occasions.” This curiosity and sense of purpose drives their action.
This call to examine sites and places outside of the ordinary has brought both pleasant and unpleasant encounters. They describe their favourite find as the spiral staircase in the Good Shepherd Convent (Photo 1). While, they also mention that the “most upsetting place I have explored has to have been walking through the tunnel from St Kevin's asylum to the church in Cork city, it's the only place I have really been affected by its energy and I have to admit I cried.” (Photo 2) 

They also emphasised that: “I have a strict code of conduct while exploring. I only enter buildings that are open, I never break in. The only thing I take are photos and the only thing I leave are footprints and needless to say I hate vandalism.”

The Abandonded West Cork account uses the potential of social media to show people places in the landscape and in urban areas that otherwise go unnoticed. They reveal a slice of cultural and social life, but also raises questions about how these buildings are treated and the different types of good they could do.
0 Comments

Cycling Cork, Knowing Cork, by Conn Donovan

6/3/2019

0 Comments

 
Picture
To fully understand Cork, one must cycle Cork. You learn fast. You learn that the city centre is at the bottom of a bowl, so you almost always roll into the city. The hard bit is getting home. You learn the weather. That the prevailing wind is usually a south westerly. That frost is rarer than you think. That it does rain, but hardly ever in the morning and the evening on the same day. You learn the names of the rivers and streams of Cork: Lee, Twopot, Bride, Tramore. They may not take a direct route, but they avoid hills and slowly meander towards the harbour.  You learn the history of the city, you learn that there was once a railway to Crosshaven. That Bishopstown is called so because a Bishop’s demesne was once there. You learn about the seasons and the planets.
​Give a bike commuter in Cork any time and date on the calendar and they’ll tell you whether it’s lighting up time or not. To know Cork takes time; days and days of cycling to and fro.

In the 1980s, 7% of trips taken in Cork city were on bicycles. By 2015, that had fallen to less than 3%; almost negligible. Hard to believe when half the car trips taken in Cork are less than 5km. A mere 20-minute cycle. Many regional European cities are striving to have 70% of people not drive to work through a combination of active and public transport. Sadly, in Cork 7 in 10 drive.  But the humble bike is on the brink of revival. 12,000 bike share users have given life back to utility cycling in Cork.  Over 5,000 new jobs are due to come on stream in the city centre in the next 2 years. Car parking spaces are at a premium so there is a hope that at least 10% of these workers will cycle to work. 500 doesn’t sound like a lot until you put 500 cars in a row on a road and send them all home at the same time.

To cycle in Cork is not only to understand Cork, but also life itself. To understand the risks posed by climate breakdown. To understand the challenges we face at the societal level by the obesity epidemic and physical inactivity. To understand that pollutants from internal combustion engines causes damage to our health.
To cycle in Cork is to know. To understand. To take action. 

0 Comments

Castletownbere: The Pier as a Significant Place, Dr Elaine O’Driscoll-Adam

5/3/2019

0 Comments

 
Picture
Castletownbere is the main town on the Beara Peninsula and is 122 kilometres from Cork city. This picturesque fishing port is located on the edge of West Cork and is the country’s largest whitefish port. The town is sheltered from the Atlantic Ocean by Bere Island which is situated two kilometres to the south and by the mountainous Beara Peninsula to the north. The harbour of Castletownbere is defined by the town pier and Dinish Island – which connects to the mainland by a bridge; it is managed by the Department of Agriculture, Food and the Marine (DAFM).

As visitors arrive to Castletownbere from the east, they pass the bridge to Dinish Island on the left. The material culture reveals itself through road signage that advertises the various local businesses attached to the fishing sector. Approaching the town centre, the presence of the Lifeboat Station and, thereafter, the many restaurants promoting local fish and seafood shows that Castletownbere is an active fishing place.

A stroll through the pier reveals its significance to Castletownbere. It symbolises many things for members of the fishing community. Like many fishing ports, it is a meeting place, a workplace, a point of departure and a point of return. At times busy, at times still, it is a focal point for the entire community. The pier and fishing boats signal the importance of fishing to the local economy to locals and visitors alike. It is a complex place with both practical and symbolic significance. While the pier remains very deeply anchored in the everyday lives of Castletownbere, it is also a place of ritual, heritage and tourism. It is
a place that can be full of life when the boats return from fishing, but also a quiet place for the wider community when boats have gone to sea. When the weather permits it is a busy place where fishing practices are performed and boats ‘come in’ and ‘go out’ to the rhythm of catches. For fishers the pier is a place of constant movement and activity where work and encounters intermingle. During periods of adverse weather conditions it becomes a meeting place for fishers. During the summer months the pier is the backdrop for festivals and events.

Festivals form an essential part of fishing communities; and in turn, places like Castletownbere, are shaped by events such as the Fishermen’s Mass and Blessing of the Boats. These rituals are ways to celebrate a living practice, yet, these customs also provide a specific place for people to commemorate and give meanings to a vernacular practice that connects local places to the wider world. The pier is a relevant place for transmitting such local traditions to subsequent generations. Festivals and rituals, linked to fishing as a way of life can be observed in coastal places worldwide. Local customs are not unique to particular places and similar customs and ‘ways of doing’ can be shared across borders.

Fishing is not merely about facts and figures, quotas and regulations. It is an industry steeped in culture; it is a way of life that is constantly evolving, yet, remains anchored to its many traditions. The willingness to explore new and different futures speaks to the resilience of the fishing community and a willingness to adapt to a changing world. For fishers and their
communities, the pier is a significant place that is the equivalent to the square in a market town. It is an in-between place where the worlds of fishers and their families, locals and visitors converge. The fishers are not quite at home, not at sea. It is a distinctive place that embodies social and cultural interaction. Fishing practice does not only consist of fishers going to sea, but encompasses a way of life that connects the fishing home, the fishing boat and the wider fishing community. The pier is a place where all members of the community, whether directly involved in fishing or not, gather and meet. For tourists and visitors, the pier is where the shore meets the sea, a place where they can create their own stories. The pier is at the heart of all fishing communities and Castletownbere is no different.

0 Comments

Cork Week - Year of Geography

5/3/2019

0 Comments

 

Disability and Rural access in West Cork, Evie Nevin

According to figures released by the Central Statistics Office (CSO), there are over 11,000 people with disabilities living in Cork South West. Evie Nevin is the Social Democrat candidate for Clonakilty-Skibbereen area. She has praised her hometown of Clonakilty for being more inclusive for families affected by Autism but is calling for further inclusivity throughout West Cork.

The mother of two lives with a disability, Ehlers Danlos Syndrome. The condition is a rare disease, which affects the connective tissue. Her two children, Alex (9) and Olivia (3) are also affected. “I wasn’t always mobility impaired and like so many people, I never thought I would be. Disability or impairments can happen so quickly through illness or an accident. Disability does not discriminate.

We are an aging population. We are living longer, so it is imperative that we put things in place for older people as well as those with disabilities. “ Of the 11,000 living with disabilities in west Cork, almost 5,000 have difficulty with activities such as climbing stairs, reaching, lifting or carrying. 

“One of my main goals should I be elected to Cork County Council is to develop a plan to make West Cork age and disability friendly. I would do this while working closely with local community groups such as the Clonakilty Access Group which has been working tirelessly to improve accessibility since 1999,” says Evie who is a part-time wheelchair user.

The local election candidate suggests that one of the first steps in making west Cork more inclusive is by making the bus routes accessible. “I have been in touch with Bus Éireann and Cork County Council about this issue.  Bus Éireann tells me they cannot provide accessible buses until the bus stops are in the right condition. The 236 and 237 are the main bus routes for West Cork. There are accessible stops in Skibbereen but they are of no use unless the actual vehicle is accessible. It also makes many travel cards obsolete if a person with a disability can’t access public transport.

“West Cork is a beautiful place with a lot to offer and it should be accessible to all residents. We also must remember that West Cork is a popular tourist destination and we are not allowing a pretty substantial portion of society to come and visit.

Ms Nevin believes West Cork can become more age and disability friendly by introducing a number of very achievable initiatives such as installing more automatic doors, ramps, levelling and decluttering of footpaths, crossings for the blind, local interpreters, looping systems and disabled bathrooms that have hoists for older children. “It is not just a disease or a disorder that disables people. Society disables us,” concludes Ms Nevin.
0 Comments

Cork Week - Year of Geography

4/3/2019

0 Comments

 

Built Upon a Swamp - ​Dr Kieran McCarthy

Picture
Cork City’s growth on a swamp is an amazing story. The city is constructed on a shift-shaping landscape – sand and gravel, rushes and reeds – a wetland knitted together to create a working port through the ages. It also provides the foundation for the multi-faceted narratives that tie this place together. There is a huge depth to this city’s development.  It was a combination of native and outside influences, primarily people who shaped its changing townscape and society since its origins as a settlement. 
​The city possesses a unique character derived from a combination of its plan, topography, built fabric and its location on the lowest crossing point of the river Lee as it meets the tidal estuary and the second largest natural harbour in the world. Indeed, it is also a city that is unique among other cities, it is the only one which has experienced all phases of Irish urban development, from circa 600 AD to the present day. There is a very diverse set of archive and library records, some of which are very complete and some which are very fractious. Hence there are many diverse public spaces, historical structures and characters listed in this book.
Standing in the city’s central Bishop Lucey Park, for example, are multiple monuments – remnants of the blocks of the town walls, the arches for the old Corn Market gates (once behind City Hall), the smiling shawlie within Seamus Murphy’s statue, and the swans of the fountain representing Cork 800. The fountain was placed there in 1985, a nod to the city’s celebration of 800 years since the city’s first charter in 1185. Then there is the imposing sinking tower of Christ Church and its ruinous graveyard. There is the ghostly feel of the buildings that once stood at the park’s entrance. Along the latter stretch, living memory has recorded Jennings furniture shop, destroyed by fire in 1970; the toy shop of Percy Diamond who was cantor (a singer of liturgical music) at the Jewish synagogue; and the Fountain Café over which the famous hurler Christy Ring had a flat for a time. Of course when I mention just these strands, there are other layers I have not mentioned. The layered memories at times and their fleshed out contexts are endless and often seem timeless.
The presence of all these monuments in the Park often plays with my own mind on every walking tour – there is so much one can show and say. These urban spaces seem to slide between the past and present, between material and symbolic worlds. The mural by Mayfield Community Arts on the gable end of the shop next door to the park, entitled “connecting our imagination, how do we imagine a positive future” is apt. The past does play on the imagination; it interconnects between spaces and times into our present and future. Memories flow and bend across the story of the development of this North Atlantic big-hearted small city.
The displayed lower sections of the town walls are from the thirteenth century. During its excavation shards of pottery from Normandy, from the Saintonge region of France, from England, and from other parts of Ireland were also found during the excavation of the wall. For nearly 500 years (1170s to 1690), the town wall symbolised the urbanity of Cork and gave its citizens an identity within the town itself. The walls served as a vast repository of symbolism, iconography and ideology and as symbols of order.
The former town walls like this city were rebuilt in parts by inhabitants through hundreds of years. The river and the tide eroded at their base taking away the various sandstone and limestone blocks and perhaps re-shaping the more resistant ones. The surviving section in Bishop Lucey Park invites the visitor to reflect on life and resistance within the town and how layered the city’s story is. There is wear and tear on the stones presented, which cross from the era of the walled town to the modern city. It invokes the imagination and if anything the wear and tear on our built heritage allows our minds to wonder and reflect about the life and times of people of the past and offers us ideas to take into our future world. 
 
From the creation of the first port, the city’s coat of arms, to building international confidence as one of the self-proclaimed Venices of Northern Europe. Cork’s historical development and ambition knew no bounds! However, certainly colonists such as the Vikings and Anglo-Normans and immigrant groups (and eventually citizens in their own right) such as Huguenots and Quakers led the settlement to have a role in the wider North Atlantic trade and beyond. All were involved in physically altering the townscape, constructing new buildings and quays and improving the interface with the river and the sea. Some key events such as Cork’s role in the Irish War of Independence in the early twentieth century also led to changes to the city’s fabric. The Burning of Cork incident led to many of its main street buildings, City Hall and Library being destroyed. The City rose from the ashes with a rebuild plan plus also strategies for the growing population and their requests for new housing areas.
The array of public spaces and buildings that the city possesses is impressive. You can get lost in and around the multiple narrow streets and broad thoroughfares. Every corner presents the visitor with something new to discover. The pigeon filled medieval tower of the Augustinian Red Abbey and the ruinous room of an old Franciscan well are rare historical jigsaw pieces that have survived the test of time. The dark dungeon at Blackrock Castle, with its canon opes, dates back to 1585 whilst the star shaped fort of Elizabeth Fort has stonework stretching way back to the early seventeenth century. The City does not have much eighteenth century built heritage left. What does exist such as the Queen Anne ‘Culture House’ on Pope’s Quay, represents an age where Dutch architecture was all the rage. A high pitched roof and elaborate and beautiful brick work combines to make a striking structure. The legacy of the city’s golden age of markets is present in the English Market, written about and critiqued since 1788.
Many architects have come and gone over the centuries but the rivalry of The Pain Brothers and the Deane family in the early nineteenth century inspired both families to excel in the design of some of the most gorgeous stone-built buildings from banks to churches to the quadrangle of UCC. All were embellished with local limestone, which on a sunny day, when the sun hits such a stone, lights up to reveal its splendour and the ambition of Ireland’s second city. The settlement is also a city of spires linking back 1,400 years to the memory of the city’s founding saint, Finbarre. The old medieval churches of St Peter and Christ Church are now arts centre but many of elements of their ecclesiastical past can be glimpsed and admired. Couple these with the beautiful St Anne’s Church tower and the scenery from the top of its pepper pot tower, the nineteenth century splendour of the spires and stained glass of St Finbarre’s Cathedral and the sandstone block work of SS Mary’s and Anne’s North Cathedral, and the visitor can get lost in a world of admiration and wider connections to Global religions. Then there is the determination that led the city to also possess the longest building in Western Europe – the old Cork Lunatic Asylum or Our Lady’s Hospital and the tallest building in the country – County Hall, and only in recent years surpassed by the Elysian Tower.
Then there are the buildings which belong to the people. The current City Hall, the second building on the site, is the home of the City Council, formerly Corporation, which was established in Anglo-Norman times. The building is a memorial to the first building, which burned down in 1920, and to the memory of two martyred Lord Mayors, Terence McSwiney and Tomás MacCurtain. Terence died on a hunger strike and Tomas was shot in his house in Blackpool, both dying for the Irish War of Independence cause. The train station, Kent Station, also links through its name to Irish Easter Rising martyr, Tomas Kent. The station is the last of six railway stations, which travelled out into the far reaches of County Cork. 
Cork’s ambition was also displayed and carried by its people – its famous sons and daughters. Cork can boast connections to the wider world through its artists, architects and sculptors. They were renowned in their day, not just in Ireland but wider afield. Artists like James Barry and Daniel Maclise brought their own unique style into Britain’s art worlds and galleries. Sculptors like John Hogan’s and later Joseph Higgins and Seamus Murphy inspired a generation of artists to take up their own artistic endeavours and created a Cork and international public who wanted to see their work.
Here is a city as well that brought forward great writers of international standing such as Denny Lane, Daniel Corkery, Seán O’Faoláin, Frank O’Connor, and Seán Ó Riordáin. Composers range from Seán O’Riada to Aloys Fleischmann. Rory Gallagher, the famous electric guitar star of his day, is also remembered and his legend recalled regularly. Dancing into memory is the great ballet dancer and director Joan Denise Moriarty.
Amongst the city’s eminent list of social reformers are Nano Nagle, Mary Aikenhead, Thomas Dix Hincks, Fr Theobald Mathew, Fr Christy O’Flynn and Br James Burke. All sought to help the city’s impoverished. Amongst the remembered political leaders is Jack Lynch who became the city’s only Taoiseach or Irish Prime Minister. Then there are the local heroes who gave the citizens employment, promoted freedom of expression, and above all showed that Cork is well able to fight for its position as Ireland’s southern capital.
I have often walked around Cork in attempt to get lost in its hidden corners, to be a tourist in my city, reading clues from bye-gone ages. The City does remember historical events– the enormous temperance campaign of Fr Mathew is immortalised in his statue on St Patrick’s Street, the National Monument commemorating Irish struggles against the British Empire before Independence. The World War I memorial on the South Mall is nestled into a nice green area and is set against the backdrop of the boardwalk.
However, weaving in and out of side streets and laneways, the visitor can get lost in the world of historical tales. Check out the city’s former Mayoral house, a street made for a cornmarket, a graveyard for deceased sailors, stories of steamships, educational morals in an art gallery, casts from the Vatican Art Gallery and tales of immigrants and their experiences from other parts of the world. Cork can boast to have a National Sculpture factory in an old tramway engine house, colourful Harry Clarke windows, a former nineteenth century waterworks made into a science centre, and an old famine relief project road, which turned into the site of world record motorcycle speed test attempt in the early twentieth century.
​
There is an underbelly to Cork’s history. It’s a city where its ambition was pushed forcefully through takeover and colonisation. One image that always strikes me are the heads on spikes in the 1575 Pacata Hibernia map of the city. As a centre of power it created tensions between those who lived within its walls and those outside. Eventually the strength of the walled town succumbed to attack by Irish and Jacobite attack and in turn they were attacked the city heavily damaged. Out of that event and an enlarging economy and population came crime in abundance. Many crimes were attempts to attain food for impoverished families. Watchmen patrolled the city’s area where most offences occurred. Many were interred in Cork City Gaol. The more malicious criminals such as murderers and anti-crown supporters were hung at Gallows Green off Bandon Road, one of the city’s large southern approach roads.
A look at the story of working life of Cork reveals a very busy city through the ages. From medieval craft-making to creating the largest butcheries in the island of Ireland, Cork citizens were dedicated to making the port of Cork the premier harbour in the North Atlantic.  Cork possessed the largest brewery and butter market in the country, hence hosting large scale employment and inspiring other businesses to root themselves in the city and region. In the twentieth century, the firms of Fords and Dunlops gave employment to thousands of Cork people whilst creating a production empire of tractors, cars, tyres and even golf balls!
Not everyone was involved in the economic boom. Life in the city for the poorer classes was a struggle. Built across a swamp, life was damp – the streets were flooded regularly by the river and the tide. Economic boom brought a population explosion. Those were not successful in securing employment filled the hallways of the poor house of the House of Industry in Blackpool and later during the Great Famine years and beyond, the Cork Union Workhouse on Douglas Road. Many left from ships on Cork’s quays bound for countries such as Great Britain and further afield such as America. The story of Annie Moore and her adventure to the metropolis of New York is representative of hundreds of thousands of people who became part of Ireland’s Irish diaspora legacy.
Scattered across the city are several sites, which have entertained the combined masses over many centuries. Take a stroll at the Mardyke, the Marina, and the Lough – they are institutions in the southern city. Barracka and Buttera Bands seem to have been around for time immemorial, entertaining citizens since the nineteenth century. Grabbing a ticket and sitting in Cork Opera House, Everyman Palace, the Firkin Crane and the Granary, the visitor can see the depth of dramatic talent and an opportunity to see the citizen uniting to support music, drama and the wider arts.  The ideas of creating a spectacle, Cork has always taken to heart. It can also boast of building show grounds, viewing towers, Turkish baths, and world fairs! So what are you waiting for take a historical walking tour!
 
Extracted from The Little Book of Cork City (2015, Irish History Press) by Kieran McCarthy, www.corkheritage.ie, @cllrkmac; facebook: Cork Our City, Our Town

0 Comments

SHARECITY: investigating the role of shared urban growing initiatives for achieving SDG11

30/10/2018

0 Comments

 

Picture
Equal access to open green space is one of the key target goals under SDG 11 for transforming cities onto more sustainable pathways because urban green space provides a range of ecosystem goods and services such as reduced air pollution and improved temperature regulation. Recently, research has uncovered additional health and well-being benefits of green spaces, particularly within urban environments, where it has been shown that just passing by green spaces can help to reduce stress, heart rate and blood pressure. In addition, research indicates that the perception of crime as well as actual crime rates are lower in neighbourhoods with access to green and open spaces. What’s more, green space can also provide a physical site for enhanced human interactions particularly through shared and collaborative practices often seen in community gardens or edible parks. These spaces of interaction have been shown to combat social dislocation and loneliness in urban environments.

As part of the SHARECITY project we are identifying, mapping, analysing and assessing the practices and sustainability potential that spaces for shared growing in urban environments provide. We are focusing on those practices of shared growing that use some form of ICT to mediate their activities and seeing what difference those technologies make to the practices and impacts of sharing. We have mapped these across 100 urban spaces globally and you can interact with them through our SHARECITY100 Database. This database was used to identify a suite of case studies in nine cities for in-depth examination with researchers spending many months in the field immersed in the activities of thirty-eight food sharing initiatives. Shared growing activities comprise a third of our sample and include a range of innovative approaches to urban sustainability challenges.

596 Acres from New York, Unites States and 3000 Acres from Melbourne, Australia, for example, seek to optimise the use of vacant land for communal growing activities. Both initiatives identify and map unused land using online tools and then provide support citizen groups to develop them into community gardens.

Other growing initiatives in the SHARECITY100 database, such as The Skip Garden and Kitchen in London, UK and Himmelbeet in Berlin, Germany, focus on creating inclusive intercultural gardens within which people can come together to share land, seeds, plants, food, compost, tools, kitchen space, knowledge, and meals through gifting and selling.

Himmelbeet is an intercultural food sharing initiative, which started in 2013. Currently, the community garden is located on vacant space in Wedding, a neighbourhood with one of Berlin’s highest unemployment rates of 26%. Himmelbeet’s main target goal is ‘The good life for all. Not more but also not less.’ The initiative enables access to healthy food and education, for some of Berlin’s inhabitants for whom this turns out to be more difficult. One of Himmelbeet’s current projects is the development of a book on gardening that is accessible to everyone, written in easy language. The ‘TUML Buch’ is composed in a collaborative manner with a diverse group working together to develop the content, but also to provide space for knowledge exchange and friendships to develop. All outputs from the process are documented online and provided for free for others to use.

However, it is not always plain sailing for such community enterprises. Later in 2018, Himmelbeet’s license to operate will cease and the land will be leased instead to a soccer organization for deprived youth, which will develop a sports and education initiative on the site where the garden currently resides. Despite trying to find a mutually agreeable compromise for the past three years Himmelbeet will now have to find a new vacant space for their activities. As a community garden they receive little protection from the state for their activities because they are not classified as a park, a school or a sports centre which have explicit teams within the local authority to plan and management developments.

Another growing initiative listed on the SHARECITY100 Database which facilitates equal access to green space here in Ireland is the Muck and Magic community garden (MaM) in Ballymun, a suburb north of Dublin city centre.

A local volunteer group based in Ballymun, Dublin started MaM as part of the Ballymun Regeneration Plan in 2011. MaM is based on a piece of land which is owned by the Dublin City Council and lease to the initiative on an annual basis. The garden operates with the help of local volunteers and gardeners from the surrounding neighbourhoods. Amongst them are members from a local day centre for adults with special needs as well as a group that attends the garden from a local drugs rehabilitation project.

Over the course of seven years, the garden, which started with four raised beds for vegetable growing, now incorporates a garden shed, poly tunnel and a series of composts. The area is also covered by ornamental trees and harbours an insect hotel. In addition, MaM has a wormery and makes its own leaf mould following a circular approach of self-subsistence.
The garden is open to everyone and welcomes new and returning volunteers for gardening afternoons. In 2014, the garden was made wheelchair accessible and a series of surface paths were incorporated into the garden design. MaM’s newest project is to develop a sensory garden which is due to open later this year which aims to enhance the outdoor experiences visitors enjoy when they visit the garden, as John from MaM notes below:

… I feel the garden has great potential for people of all category of needs. I remember actually, the St. Michaels House Group, they invited us actually to the center one day for lunch […] what really struck me was I was asking about what other activities they have during the week and they all really are indoor activities you know and really, to spend half a day in an open air environment like our garden and having just an environment where there is to be lots of space around them and I can see it has a number of benefits…
                                                       John O’Donoghue – Initiator and participant at MaM community garden

SHARECITY is working with MaM to co-design a sustainability impacts toolkit to help them establish exactly what kinds of impacts their work has on participants. This research will be published soon on our website!

Taking a closer look at shared growing initiatives, as the SHARECITY project is doing, confirms multiple potential benefits for urban populations. However, it also shows that more work has to be done on establishing exactly the kinds of benefits that emerge from growing together and who exactly is benefitting from such activities. Similarly the governance of shared urban food growing is embryonic and this could undermine the achievement of optimal sustainability benefits from green spaces as community gardens and other edible initiatives fail to receive adequate attention and protection from land use planning authorities and other regulatory bodies. By better defining the benefits emerging from shared food growing and the kinds of regulatory actions needed to support them, we hope that the target goals under SDG 11 as well as other goals around hunger (SDG2) and responsible production and consumption (SDG 12) become achievable.

Picture
0 Comments
<<Previous

    Author

    Posts are mostly by Irene the PRO but are welcome from all members of the society. Just email us your articles.

    Archives

    July 2019
    May 2019
    March 2019
    October 2018
    September 2018
    August 2018
    July 2018
    June 2018
    May 2018
    April 2018
    March 2018
    January 2018
    November 2017
    October 2017
    July 2017
    May 2017

    Categories

    All
    Environment
    Resources

    RSS Feed

Geography Society of Ireland, 2018